The Cringiest Love Is Blind Moments Ever

Besides, you know, everything cringey about Shake’s reunion performance, one especially awkward moment came when he was defending his lack of attraction to ex-fiancée Deepti—and his attraction to someone who wasn’t even on the cast.

“Every woman here is beautiful. I think you’re all beautiful. I’m not attracted to all of you. Unfortunately, the only one I’m attracted to is Vanessa [Lachey],” he said, to noises of disgust from his castmates. “And I wish I wasn’t! I wish I wasn’t. The point is, it’s not a choice. It’s nature, baby. We’re animals.” 

In response, her husband and co-host Nick Lachey referenced Shake’s veterinary career, firing back, “No, you treat animals. We’re human beings. There’s a big difference. Now I see why you don’t treat human beings.” Yikes.