Polish lawmakers reach compromise on judicial reforms | Courts News

Warsaw says a bill proposing changes to Poland’s legal system will unblock billions of euros of European Union funding.

Lawmakers from Poland’s ruling coalition have agreed to judicial reforms the government says will unblock billions of euros of European Union funding, helping the country’s economy as it grapples with the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in neighbouring Ukraine.

More than 35 billion euros ($37bn) of COVID recovery grants and loans have been put on hold due to a dispute with Brussels over the rule of law, but Warsaw has said it had reached an agreement on terms to unblock the funds and expects approval from the EU in the coming days.

The judicial reform bill agreed on Thursday is key to this.

“In the coming months already, this money will start to flow from the EU budget,” Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki told reporters.

Legislators debating the bill in a parliamentary commission took proposals from President Andrzej Duda as the basis of the reforms, but the archconservative United Poland party, which is a junior partner in government, objected to an impartiality test for judges which it said could paralyse the system.

Under amendments agreed on Thursday, an article that would have allowed verdicts already handed down to subsequently be challenged on grounds of impartiality was removed, state-run news agency PAP reported.

Provisions for an independence test for judges in unfinished cases remained in the bill.

A preamble referring to the primacy of the Polish constitution over norms established by international organisations such as the EU was also added as a result of a United Poland amendment.

“I am very glad that the commission has adopted the president’s … draft bill,” Duda’s representative Malgorzata Paprocka was quoted as saying by PAP. “I hope that the end is in sight and it will soon become binding law.”

The bill would replace the Disciplinary Chamber of the Supreme Court, which critics say is politicised, with a new body.

Huge fines

The EU says Warsaw must implement a ruling from the bloc’s top court that requires it to dissolve the chamber in order to get the funds.

The top EU court has imposed fines on Poland of one million euros ($1.05m) a day for failing to do so.

Critics say the reform does not go far enough in ensuring judges are not subject to political pressure.

Parliament may vote on the bill before the end of the month.

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, for her part, said on Tuesday that Poland would have to prove that it had met the necessary conditions “before any disbursement under the Recovery and Resilience Facility could take place”.