Amanda Seyfried Has The Best Response to Idea ofMamma Mia 3

And just like Amanda, Colin—who plays Harry—wants the gang back together. “And if people want it,” Colin, 61, said, “I would do it just to see my friends again on some beautiful island.”

Though Amanda hasn’t yet been approached about actually doing a third film, that doesn’t mean it can’t happen, she says.

“I know if you ask any of the others they’ll be like, ‘Sure, but it’s not going to happen,'” she told Variety. “But then that’s what we said about the second one, and it was better than the first one! It’s just so fun.”